"Is drinking them a good idea?" For one who knows what this stuff is, and secondly if Carlisle is sort of still dead then can he digest anything? Will it just sit in his stomach until he throws up?

"I understand wanting to get away from yourself, but maybe you need something I dunno.. magical?" Did that make sense? He felt like it did - yet he didn't really know what Carlisle's world was like. He assumed everything was magical, some sort of Harry Potter land but far more dangerous and real. He can hear the disappointment in Carlisle's voice though, and he definitely knows the sensation of wanting to drink the pain away.